You’re Not Shy, You’re Spiraling: When Social Anxiety Hides Behind High Achievement

Written By Yuxin Sun

You’re Polite. You’re Charming. You’re Dying Inside.

Let’s talk about social anxiety—but make it high-functioning.

Because you’re not hiding in your house.
You’re going to events. Leading meetings. Nodding at small talk like a pro.

But also?

  • You replay every conversation after it happens

  • You worry that your “face” didn’t match your tone

  • You cancel plans and then panic about being forgotten

  • You feel fake, awkward, or like you’re being watched—even if you’re the one in charge

And people tell you you’re “so confident.”
Which is hilarious. And kind of sad.

When Social Anxiety Doesn’t Look Like Anxiety

A lot of high-achieving, socially anxious adults fly under the radar because they’re performing their personality like a full-time role.

What people don’t see:

  • The rehearsals before phone calls

  • The avoidance of initiating plans, even with friends

  • The stress-induced insomnia after one slightly weird interaction

  • The internal monologue that won’t shut up

  • The need to “earn” your right to exist in any group

You’re not antisocial. You’re exhausted.

Where Does This Come From?

Social anxiety isn’t just about being “nervous.” It’s often shaped by:

  • Being told you were “too sensitive” growing up

  • Growing up in high-pressure or critical environments

  • Cultural expectations around how to “present”

  • Feeling like you’re always performing to be accepted

  • Trauma, rejection, or long-standing shame

And when you’re also a high-achiever?
You hide it really, really well. Until you can’t.

Therapy Helps. Even If You Think It’s Not “That Bad.”

At Sunburst Psychology, we specialize in working with socially anxious professionals, perfectionists, and overthinkers in Seattle, Bellevue, and across the Eastside.

What we do in therapy:

  • Untangle the anxious thought loops without judgment

  • Identify the root (not just the symptoms) of your spirals

  • Help you show up without needing a mask

  • Teach your nervous system that social = safe (eventually)

  • Create a space where you don’t have to prove anything to be liked

This isn’t “just be yourself” advice. This is real, deep, supportive work that actually shifts things.

A Few Survival Tips While You Get There

1. Notice your exit strategies.

Do you ghost? Overshare? Joke too much? Get overly formal? All are valid. All are also clues.

2. Challenge the “spotlight effect.”

No one’s thinking about your awkward handshake. They’re too busy wondering if they sounded weird.

3. Try “safe people” experiments.

Practice naming your anxiety out loud in low-stakes settings: “Hey, I always feel weird at events like this.” Magic happens.

4. You don’t have to fix it all before seeking help.

You’re allowed to be anxious in therapy. That’s literally what it’s for.

Looking for social anxiety therapy in Seattle or Bellevue?
You don’t have to hide behind high-functioning forever.
Schedule a consultation with Sunburst Psychology.
Let’s help you feel less like you’re performing your personality—and more like you’re living it.

Start Here
Yuxin Sun
Next

Is My Child’s Behavior Normal or a Sign of Something Deeper?